Community management is not always well respected, but it requires some of the most important “people skills” that games need to keep their environments friendly and welcoming to players.
Subscribe for new episodes every Wednesday! http://bit.ly/SubToEC (—More below)
(Original air date: November 20, 2013)
_______
Get your Extra Credits gear at the store! http://bit.ly/ExtraStore
Play games with us on Extra Play! http://bit.ly/WatchEXP
Watch more episodes from this season of Extra Credits! http://bit.ly/2qMiJ6G
Contribute community subtitles to Extra Credits: http://www.youtube.com/timedtext_cs_panel?c=UCCODtTcd5M1JavPCOr_Uydg&tab=2
Talk to us on Twitter (@ExtraCreditz): http://bit.ly/ECTweet
Follow us on Facebook: http://bit.ly/ECFBPage
Get our list of recommended games on Steam: http://bit.ly/ECCurator
_________
Would you like James to speak at your school or organization? For info, contact us at: contact@extra-credits.net
_________
♪ Intro Music: “Penguin Cap” by CarboHydroM
http://bit.ly/1eIHTDS
♪ Outro Music: “Ghosts of Reach” by Nato
source
This is going to be a bigger and bigger deal as we scale
It's not just the gaming industry. Across the board, job roles based on managing the social space are undervalued or maligned, despite how lacking many employees are in social ettiquite and finesse. I think it's that most people don't notice or care about their social faults, and they dont see the effects their small actions have on the environment (and how that impacts the bottom line). That results in them not seeing how important these social mediator roles are. This is true in HR, PR, community management, etc.
We all know that Nintendo has terrible community management right? (Or at least from what I've heard.)
i would say community managers tend to be a bit more important now a perfect example is the community manager for Fall guys helped make that game blow up
Great community managers are fantastic! I played Dream of Mirror Online under Aeria games and for all the mess that could be, some of the GMs were great. I loved running into them randomly sometimes, higher level than everyone else, decked out in rare amazing gear and just chatting a bit. And their events were fun too, each GM liked to run different types of event and it was fun to participate. It felt like you could communicate with the company, even if that was necessarily true.
This episode is a real hidden gem! I’ve been watching old extra credits videos for a long time and it’s only just now been recommended to me!
Ubisoft has shown us that QA is important 🤣
DE has some great community managers
Did Extra Credit forgot this episode existed?
Is this video still relevant? Planning to apply as a CM for a gaming company. Pls reply
So Hi I am from 2019 things got crazy dude and they still get a hard time😢
Is it worth it, becoming a community manager
Really enjoyed this and it raises some important points on the value of CM's in the industry and their key role in the positive side of people management – that of bringing new people together and growing new communities – and the limitation of the negative side – stepping into moderate and tackling the difficult issues. That's getting more and more important as the focus is placed on Facebook and Twitter and tackle abuse, bullying and other challenging aspects of online interactions.
It's a real shame the CM's aren't seen as, and rewarded for, the value they provide and can be due to difficulties in proving their value, especially when faced with objectives that can't be measured in numbers, like your gamers culture. It is possible though with well thought out objectives and good storytelling combining numbers and verbatim feedback. For anyone who'd like to learn more about that and growing communities in general, check out my channel at https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZUVONLmlILrAkoSPTVWUoA
3:20
Poor Jeff Kaplan. He does his best yet gets memed into oblivion
Soooo, you're saying I could get an easy job in community management? 😀
While I'm not a game community manager, I am a moderator for a fairly large Twitch streamer who happens to be a friend of mine. He often puts the spotlight on I and my fellow moderators because of all the work we do to keep our community a friendly and enjoyable place to be, and we're thankful for it. I absolutely believe that game community managers deserve the same kind of respect and recognition. They, much like us, are doing the best they can while dealing with often times rude and entitled people, or people just trying to get them to flip out on them. So kudos to any and all game community managers out there actively trying to make the community a fun and enjoyable place to be.
1. Ensure they actually had the item, a recipt or some purchase information would suffice, and restore the item if they did indeed have it. Not quite what they want, but I'm not in a position to give them that refund. Restoring the item, however, would at least solve the problem.
2. Depends on the rules and the rating of the game. If this game is meant to be pg 13 at worst, check to see if the player has been warned in the past. Let's give them a 3 strikes your out here, but it depends on the rules and how strict. If they aren't on 2 strikes, warn them. Otherwise, give them a temporary mute from chat. If the game is meant for mature audiences, I think I'd let it slide in terms of punishment, but attempt to calm the user down. If I'm actually in-game, maybe I'd offer to help him with whatever he's doing that's causing this frustration. If I'm not high enough level or this is on forums, I could at least offer advice.
3. Take a record of the forum where this is occurring, taking screenshots of every message on said topic, then lock the topic, and issue a warning to each user individually, if not temporarily ban them from the forum for a week or so, depending on how bad it was and just how long it had gone on from.. Lace my words with honey with the whales/popular guys, something to the effect of "Come on, man. I know you're better than that. You're like a hero to the community, we hate to have to punish you over something like this." Also, issue a formal apology to the harassed person, assuring them that those forum members do not represent the community, and that they have been reprimanded.
Can we all just appreciate Eric Pope here? He's the community manager for For Honor and for how toxic that community can be, he's still respected amongst them.
Voice Crack 😂
3:19 LOL THE ANIMATION k sorry back to the video
If anyone has played a small multiplayer indie game before that not a lot of people know about so you need to manually organize players to get enough people. You know how great a good community can be to play with. I'm specifically referring to the game A Heist Gone Wrong btw, look it up it deserves more people. I'm sure lots of other people know of similar small and tight-knit community's.
One of those situations actually happened with The Mittani harassing an EVE player. IIRC he was banned for 1/2 year.
I've played Magic The Gathering and Pokémon for over a year and I started working on my own TCG a few months ago, I've been working alone but my friends have helped me in play testing it. Thanks for your videos, I'll do my best to work towards what you said
Two words: Fur Fun
tibia has had a community management test sinc ei started playing and it was in the early 2000s, the Test has also gotten waaaaaaay harder over the years, so yes, as much as faulty as CIpsoft is, they doc are about "hiring" or at least using, qualified people for that position.
If I was the one moderating the community in the game and they'll using offensive or sexual language I would give them a warning to stop or else face a ban if they continue I've Ban them
This is so odd compared to games like petsites, where the main community managers are also mods. Because of this they get a ton of influence and often abuse that power/tend to shut out people who are critical of the game but… pet sims are a really weird (and not really talked about) genre of online game anyway.
programmers can program
designers can design
and artists can art
Good community management: Blizzard
Bad community management: Niantic
Overwatch has great management and Pokémon go does not
At this exact moment, extra credits has 999k subs
In order: "I'm sorry but I'm not sure if it is possible to get a refund for that item but it won't be promised that you will be able to get it back. I'll see what I can do and it might be a few days (4 of them) until all the details are resolved and we can answer you and maybe email you on your situation. I thank you for your time in contacting us." "Excuse me, but that isn't the language allowed for this kind of area. Please stop this or there will be a response placed on you for your actions." The action taken is to not permaban but stop them for a day at the least and try to contact the player getting insulted to see if they are well and offer help where possible. And.. even if two of them are HIGHLY paying players, it should be clear that no one is above the law of the land that is provided to them. For the good scenario, we need to see if we can offer a giveaway or celebration item lottery or event that can be accessed for all the community.
HATS
I just got a soylent commercial with a little robot creature which was channeling Gladus… not sure how I feel about that.
SWTOR Customer Service is the best i have seen
Does anyone have any examples of bad community managers? If so, reply to this comment, and state what game the manager is from.
I appreciate these cogent remarks on this subject. As a graduate in sociology and political science, I'm all too familiar with the undervaluation of these "soft skills", even among social science undergrads. The irony is that the notion of "soft" and "hard" skills, or soft and hard science, is a completely sociological concept called the hierarchy of sciences which was coined by August Comte, one of the first explicit sociologists.
So we criticize the soft sciences while failing to notice that we wouldn't have the means to criticize it unless we accepted the merit of some of its explanations. Confused? Me too.
Three words.
Path Of Exile.
They have THE best community management of all the games I have played. It's one of the reasons I've logged over 1.7k hours into their game. I think they deserve more love because of this. check the game out if you're a fan of diablo 2 games or ARPGs!
oh my god the little hiccup/voice crack at 3:19 killed me. i love that they kept it in and even animated it!
On the HIC side
If the biggest people are being racist I would ban them in chat
In games like DOTA…it's a necessity to clean and keep the game good !
"Designers are filled with mystical systems arcana" most acurate description of a Designer yet xD
What about a "So you wanna be a community manager" video?
makes me think about pokemon go
Thumbnail: The pitchfork and torch crowd have put the community manager in the werewolf and vampire group